I agree totally with Bill Wellham. Back at the start there was lots of crossover and labels didn't matter (still don't in fact!). The band I was in started as straight ahead punk rock Clash clones and mutated into what would now be called Goth. Back then it didn't even have a name and no real scene outside London to speak of where Sex Gang Children, Southern Death Cult, Theatre of Hate and a few others were "positive punk" (remember that people? Vague fanzine did a big piece...) It was supposed to be a reaction against the nihilism and pointless anarchy-pose of the Pistols and their followers - The Exploited, Chron Gen Anti-Pasti, all things Oi! etc etc. Alternative music with a message of hope, positivity, a "can-do" attitude and anything is possible in a personal and socio-politcal context..Sounds like total wank when all you want to do is dance, play bass, drink and meet girls, but I was only 14....For what it's worth I have quite a narrow view of Goth. Sex Gang, SDC, ToH, Sisters of Mercy, Fields of the Nephilum, Mission...and maybe a couple of other bands that grew up around The Batcave scene. Remember many Batcave regulars were also psychobillies stomping at the Klub Foot! Does good music really need a label?

