You should get a "ball park" sound from either of the Danelectros they're both loaded with single coils. The Jagmaster is all humbuckers... but I'm sure, sorta sure, that they used to have a single coil loaded in the neck position?? But them maybe I do get too drunk before going out to shows? but anyway that'll change the sound a bit, you'll still get that warm cleanish neck position sound but a bit thicker, maybe a little thicker than you want. Personally I'd go with either of the dano's, I've never found them thin sounding but I do use a fair amount of fuzz and overdrive. I wouldn't worry about what the drummer thinks, it your ears that you need to please.

