Ken:
I think you're right on about this...it's all about these overpriced Record Store Day Specials....limited edition, overpriced, a lot of mainstream acts, re-issues, the trendy indie act of the day etc... An overabundance of records. To me, it looks like a cash grab by certain record labels, to sell stuff that would collect dust if it was released at any other time.
It's supposed to be about the indy record stores, the ones that sell the local singles, the hard to find imports, the re-issues, the garagepunk releases, the unauthorized live records, the used stuff, etc etc...The place where they know your name when you walk in the door and say something along the lines of 'we just got this stack of records in, and there's a couple that you probably want if you don't have them already'. The place where you never have enough coin to get everything you want, but you know it'll probably still be there next visit. The place where you bring your out of town buds who find something they've been looking for ages and get totally stoked! That's the place! And i sure don't need RSD Specials to visit, it's just extra clutter that gets in the way of what i'm looking for! And besides, i can't justify spending well over $10 (some were as high as $16!!) for a 7" of material i already have in a different form.
And no, i didn't buy any of the specials, dug through the singles boxes and found a half dozen or so that i'm spinning now and really digging!
Ken said:
That said... and speaking as a former record store owner... I think Record Store Day has become kinda flawed. The basic idea that there should be an appreciation day for these great local shops is a good one, but right now its primarily focused on the RSD specific goodies as the impetus for getting folks into the shop. The good record stores for that day have become synonymous with the ones that can lay their hands on the most goodies. (To be subsequently run up on ebay the next day to capitalize on their "scarcity.")